Pakistan Governance Model: Beg, Borrow and Steal

Discussing the developments of Faisal Shahzad’s arrest on a Pakistani TV channel this week, I was asked: why is America against Muslims. Reducing American actions to ideology is not only simplistic but also obscures critical analysis.

Why is it that Muslims from Qatar or Oman: Muslims from India, Bangladesh, Malaysia or Indonesia not under scrutiny? Why is it that a Pakistani has to go through “enhanced” security measures at American airports while Muslims of many other countries walk with their heads high? If we are judged by the company we keep ask yourself why you are in the company of Afghanistan, Somalia, Sudan, Nigeria, Libya and Syria? Ask yourself what is common between these nations?

In my opinion these countries are defined by the absence of mature governance model and corrupt, uneducated, greedy leadership.
Why is that we don’t have highly educated Pakistanis in parliament and cabinets? Where are our PhDs hiding? Why isn’t Proferssor Manzoor Ahmad, Pervez Hoodbhoy or Ayesha Siddiqui running the management of country?

I believe in past six decades we have nourished a culture that protects and respects illiterate thieves- not only in politics but also business. A handful of privileged and filthy rich Pakistanis collude to artificially raise prices of important commodities like sugar and cotton.

I always wonder how a nation in the throes of one war and a half on two fronts, an undernourished, calamity stricken nation like Pakistan condones such behavior on the part of a few rich, self-interested people. These people are the real terrorists of the land; they deserve to be caught, imprisoned and punished for the way in which they are corroding the economy of Pakistan, and by their ill devised foreign policy diluting our brand in the world.

Look closer at these robbers and you will find them in military uniforms, parliament, senate and cabinets. These corrupt elite of Pakistan are responsible for not only destroying economy but their adventurism has put us in harms way.

Why is it that Pakistanis are under microscope in the US and Europe? It is because our military leaders with modest IQ and strong muscles can twist arms (or abduct or kill or both) anyone who does not agree with them.

Pakistani entrepreneurs have learned that they can make crazy profit by playing by the rules of army bosses. And, Pakistani journalists realize that their job security comes from perpetrating the propaganda of men in uniforms.

Last September, a largely unknown raid at the premises of the Pakistan Sugar Mills Association revealed that a number of sugar mill owners had formed a cartel like structure and were engaged in “extensive institutionalization of collusive behavior.”

The agency, which has been struggling to make a foothold for its antitrust laws in Pakistan’s largely feudal economic climate, established how the affluent owners of the 82 sugar mills planned to raise the price of sugar by unfair pricing practices.

Guess who owns these sugar mills? 35% are owned by retired Pakistan army officials and another 40% are owned by the leaders of two major political parties.

Why Pakistani nation is not outraged?

While Pakistan was still struggling through the sugar crisis, unscrupulous parties and untoward economic conditions seem to have come together to create another commodity crisis in Pakistan, this time, of cotton.

Cotton prices rose to Rs 7000 per maund in April. The new crop is yet to arrive, and various international bans and embargos have produced a big deficit in the available amount of cotton. People with old stocks of cotton are taking advantage of the situation to make a killing, knowing that they are killing the economy itself. In just a short week last month, there was a Rs 1000 appreciation in the price of prime stock cotton while the textile industry pitted against peers to buy as much of the previous year’s stock as they could.

And, guess who owned majority of the old stocks? Three retired Major Generals in Punjab- had hoarded a large lot. Several well wishers of Mian family and a very close ally of Mr. Gillani.

The country has been most hit by a ban on import from India, Pakistan’s principal supplier of cotton. Pakistan has had to buy cotton at high rates from expensive sellers of other countries.

Pakistan’s textile industry has to supply pending orders from foreign buyers in the developed world, and cotton bought at very high prices kills their margin. And, this calamity has also raised the price of cotton domestically, and that does not bode well for the ordinary Pakistani, who now has to shell out more than twice as much as the old price of cotton. Prices of garment in Pakistani markets have become unbearable for a middle class family to even purchase uniforms for their school going children.

Why are Pakistani people not outraged? Why are Pakistani journalists not talking about this?

Overall Pakistan need to import at least 1.5 million bales of cotton to contain the crisis. The deficit is a shock, because India, with very similar climactic and soil conditions, has a record surplus this year.

The Karachi Cotton Association has fixed the official spot rate, or base price of Grade 3 cotton, at Rs 7180 per maund. At such prices, ordinary citizens of Pakistan will find it very hard to buy and wear cotton this year.

With severe economic crisis at hand, Pakistani leaders go around the world to beg and borrow, while they continue to steal from their own people.

And, guess what is your favorite TV anchor doing right now? Preparing a show that will ask the same question: why does America hate Muslims? Please remind them it is not religion – it is their policies.